Margaret Sargsyan

Public, professional, and social media discussions regarding general education involve almost all stakeholders: policymakers, school administrators, parents, experts, non-governmental organizations, and various other users. Yet, the voice of the very person who directly carries out the educational process—the teacher—is often relegated to the background. In our society, the teacher is cast in the role of a mere executor of others’ will. Teachers are constantly subjected to scrutiny and suspicion; consequently, few aspire to enter the profession. A teacher’s work is either viewed with pity—implying that, being unable to do anything else, they ended up working in a school—or it is framed through outdated and long-obsolete notions, such as being a “noble calling” or a “lofty mission.” Being detached from reality—failing to see the actual teacher—leads to a situation where the progress of general education becomes linked to unrealistic objectives and approaches that are disconnected from life and the human being.

Teachers are remembered when it comes time for professional development, when poor results are recorded somewhere, or when an unacceptable, condemnable incident occurs at a school…

Such discussions intensified following the release of the PISA results. While the analysis of these results typically becomes a subject of broad public discourse, the logic of the conversation often centers not on a comprehensive diagnosis of the educational system, but rather on the search for someone to hold accountable. Former and current officials, representatives from various levels of educational administration, school principals, parents, and—most frequently—teachers find themselves the targets of criticism. Meanwhile, the underlying, deepening problem remains unaddressed—a problem that transcends the simple identification of the “guilty” or the “innocent”…

I will not write about the methodology of the assessment, how to prepare for it, or other related matters. There is a vast amount of material available—look for it, and you will find it. There are interesting analyses, reactions, and reflections… Naturally, there is a lot of poor-quality content; just bypass that—it’s pointless. I want to discuss PISA from a different perspective. A prestigious international assessment… We participated… The results were disappointing, and we were surprised… We were surprised that a teacher who relies on rote memorization—and who lives within an environment defined by rote memorization—lacks creativity and fails to cultivate skills for thinking, analyzing, and experimenting. But why are we surprised? Through the voluntary certification process, we test the mastery of complex, rote-memorized material—and we do so using a flawed, outdated, and demeaning approach. We test content that has no practical application and is geared entirely toward rote memorization. So, if an elementary school teacher doesn’t happen to know some extremely rarely used words, does that mean they can’t teach? If they haven’t memorized archaic terms or complex syntactic nuances, are they incapable of consulting a dictionary or looking something up in a book? We fail to cultivate the most essential skill in our teachers: the habit of learning—the capacity to learn continuously and a genuine love for learning. If a teacher lacks this—if they are merely someone who memorizes and repeats—they will demand the same from their students. Furthermore, such teachers are easy to manage, as are their students: it’s all just rote memorization—you assign it, you test it—requiring neither real effort nor critical thought.

Why must a teacher, who already holds a higher education degree, repeatedly overcome hurdles designed to “verify” their professional knowledge? If we harbor doubts—and perhaps rightly so—let us instead start from a different point: let us strengthen our universities. Let graduating from a university and receiving a diploma become difficult; those who do not study should not receive one. In this way, the university will gain purpose, and there will no longer be constant doubts.

Here arises one of the significant contradictions in the current management of general education. On one hand, the educational system expects teachers to demonstrate autonomy, creativity, the ability to foster critical thinking, an individualized approach, and the use of innovative methods. On the other hand, a teacher’s work is often governed by numerous mechanisms for oversight, accountability, and inspection.

This also applies to the culture of assessment. If the ultimate outcome of learning is primarily linked to performance on standardized test tasks, there is a risk that the content of instruction will be adapted to meet the requirements of the test. Under such conditions, a teacher might place greater emphasis on the reproduction of information rather than on its application, analysis, or use in new situations. In other words, a teaching practice may emerge that is effective for the test, but not for developing the skills that the educational system identifies as its goals.

This is particularly important in the context of PISA, as the logic underlying PISA focuses not merely on the possession of knowledge, but on its application to real-life problems. Consequently, if an educational system aims to improve its results in such assessments, the solution is not simply to administer more tests or to train teachers in how to work with test-based tasks. Instead, it is necessary to foster a pedagogical environment in which learners have regular opportunities to interpret, synthesize, justify, solve problems, and formulate their own conclusions.

From this perspective, a teacher’s professional autonomy is not a secondary issue, but one of systemic significance. It is impossible to cultivate a creative teacher solely through professional development training if the institutional environment in which they work limits their capacity to make professional decisions. A teacher’s continuous professional development must be accompanied by professional trust, peer collaboration, and mechanisms for providing feedback on teaching practice.

Therefore, discussions surrounding PISA results could become more productive if they shifted from asking “who is to blame?” to “what conditions led to this outcome?”

This approach entails a policy review across at least several areas.

Ultimately, the culture of how responsibility is distributed—within both political and public discourse on general education—needs to change. Teachers cannot be held responsible for every problem within the educational system; likewise, neither the Ministry of Education nor a school principal can fully account for students’ educational outcomes. An educational outcome is a systemic result, and it requires systemic responsibility.

In this context, a teacher should be viewed not merely as an end-point executor of educational policy, but as a key partner in its implementation and refinement. If the educational system aims to develop learners into independent thinkers, proactive individuals, and problem-solvers, then these same principles must also apply to the teacher. It is the free, thoughtful, and creative teacher who encourages and shapes the free, creative, and thoughtful learner. It is quite simple. Think about it.